Favourite films? Or just the best?

I know what my favourite ten films are. But over the last couple of days I have been very geeky and have given several films I like scores in various categories, weighted the categories, and ranked the films quantitatively. I was surprised that some films performed much better or worse than I expected. For example, one of my top 10 finished in 15th and a film I expected to be mid-teens came 7th.
It is clear that this method I used, while designed to examine each film critically, does not give an entirely accurate picture of my personal favourites (though the top 5 at least are pretty spot on).

I scored the films out of 10 in nine categories: plot, characters, themes, script, acting, mood, visual, audio and re-watchability. I weighted each section to give a final score out of 200, and the results of the 26 films scored so far are below. However this is not exactly a rank of my personal favourites, but rather an attempt to objectively decide what I think are the best films I have seen. Obviously I have seen more than 26 films, so there may be films I have not scored yet that will enter this top 26.

Rank	Film	Score
1	The Lord Of The Rings	197
2	Gladiator	176
3	The Matrix	170
4	The Green Mile	167
5	Stardust	166
6	Shrek	161
7	Shrek 2	159
8	Fight Club	158
9	Minority Report	158
10	The Man In The Iron Mask	157
11	Good Will Hunting	157
12	The Shawshank Redemption	156
13	A Beautiful Mind	155
14	Chariots of Fire	154
15	Notting Hill	152
16	Moulin Rouge	148
17	Cool Runnings	147
18	Equilibrium	145
19	Forrest Gump	143
20	Usual Suspects	143
21	X-men trilogy	142
22	Monsters Inc	139
23	The Rock	138
24	Toy Story 2	137
25	Finding Nemo	134
26	Toy Story	129

Clearly I am quite a harsh marker. Only 7 films got over 80%. According to the star rating, thats only 7 5-star films. Luckily I think the star system is a sham and don't use it. But I don't deny I am hard to please when it comes to films. They're all measured against a ludicrously high benchmark (see film #1!).
For now this system will suffice, but I don't really like marking out of 10 because I often get split between two numbers. So sometime I'll probably redo it scoring each category out of 20. Good times.